In the early to mid-1990s, gay men in Indianapolis kept vanishing, and no one had any idea what was happening to them. That was, until police were led to a man named Brian, which they soon learned was an alias for a successful Indiana business owner named Herb Baumeister. When law enforcement was eventually allowed to search his sprawling 18-acre property in Hamilton County, what they found was truly horrifying– around 10,000 bone fragments in the woods surrounding the house. Days after the gruesome discovery, Baumeister ended his own life, so any shot at charging him died too. Despite never being convicted for a crime related to the bodies found on his property, authorities believe that Baumeister is one of the country’s most prolific serial killers, with over one dozen victims. “The Fox Hollow Murders: Playground of a Serial Killer” told the story of the tragedies that transpired at Fox Hollow Farm, its victims, and the investigation into what exactly happened. “Return to Fox Hollow: New Victims, Darker Secrets,” picks up where the 2025 docuseries left off, and director Alex Jablonski joined “Forbes True Crime” to discuss.
Watch the full interview above.